Senior education group critical of exam results – claiming ‘significant inconsistencies at learner and subject level within individual schools’

A range of concerns surrounding today’s A Level results have been voiced by a group representing senior positions in education across North Wales.

In a ‘regional statement’ issued this morning the six education portfolio holders representing the 6 North Wales Local Authorities, their Chief Officers, the Regional School Improvement Consortium, GwE and secondary headteachers say they “would like to congratulate all Year 12 and 13 learners on their achievements this year. We know that some learners will be very happy with the results they have achieved and it will allow them to go on to the next steps in their careers.”

The statement then moves on to stronger stuff, “However, on behalf of those learners, their parents and schools who have been disappointed and possibly let down by the standardisation process adopted here in Wales, we would like to seek reassurance from Welsh Government that pupils in North Wales will not be disadvantaged and miss opportunities to attend the university, further education or employment pathway of their choice when compared to their peers in other countries in the UK, especially Scotland.”

“Following receipt of the results this morning, a significant number of schools report that they have no understanding or confidence in the standardisation process adopted in Wales which has led to significant inconsistencies at learner and subject level within individual schools. The lack of transparency is very concerning.”

Some of the issues the group say have been raised by schools are:

• Number of schools reporting significant disparity between centre assessed grades and grades awarded by WJEC at AS and A Level.
• Several examples of learners of equal ability in a subject which were awarded the same grade by the centre having at least 2 grade difference between them after standardisation by WJEC.
• Methodology used by schools for awarding CAGs seems to be at odds with standardised grades.
• School Leaders can’t understand the rationale behind the inconsistency.  It is clear that individual learners have been let down and unfairly treated.
• Schools concerned that learners in Wales will lose out to other parts of UK especially Scotland.
• Early decision needs to be made as clearing will be starting imminently.
• Concerns regarding emotional wellbeing following individual learners not being awarded grades they deserve or anticipated on top of months of stress due to the COVID-19 situation
• Evidence base behind these statements seems to be growing as more information coming in.
• HTs are in a very difficult position of communicating grades to learners as they have no or limited confidence in the awards that they are sharing.
• Some examples are:
  • Centre Assessment grade A downgraded to D.
  • Centre Assessment grade B downgraded to U.

The statement goes on to say, “The matter has been further compounded following the significant U-turns seen in both Scotland and England. If ever there was a need for consistency across the UK qualifications bodies it is now. It seems that in Wales there is a grave danger that protecting the examination brand is more important than recognising the needs of leaners, especially the most vulnerable in these unprecedented circumstances that we are managing. The late announcement last night that a learner’s final A level grade will not be lower than their AS grade does not in any way address our concerns around the standardisation process but actually goes some way to acknowledge that Welsh Government themselves are not comfortable with the outcomes of the adopted process. We are also concerned and question that the Appeals process that is in place is no longer fit for purpose.”

The group also warn the same could happen again next week for GCSE students: “We want to put on record that we have equal concerns about what may happen to our GCSE learners next week as this process has not filled us with confidence and that there is no meaningful appeals process for learners to appeal against the grades they might receive.”

Top picture, Cllr Phil Wynn the ‘portfolio holder’ or Lead Member for Education in Wrexham.